Skirl and skronk in Primrose Hill
On the way home from Matt Carmichael’s London Jazz Festival gig at Cecil Sharp House last night, I started scribbling a list of great Scottish jazz musicians. Beginning with the trumpeter Tommy McQuater and the trombonist George Chisholm, who established their reputations before World War Two, I skipped to the more recent generation of the saxophonists Tommy Smith and Raymond MacDonald. When I tried to fill in the gap between those poles, there were just too many names: the baritone saxophonist Joe Temperley, the clarinetists Sandy Brown and Archie Semple, the singer Annie Ross, the cornetist Alex Welsh, the pianist Pat Smythe, the trumpeter Jimmy Deuchar, the tenorist Bobby Wellins, the bassists Jack Bruce and Ron Mathewson, the guitarist Jim Mullen, the drummer Bobby Orr, and more.
So Scotland’s gift to jazz has been considerable, and Carmichael is the latest instalment. A young tenor saxophonist, he arrived in London with his seven-piece band — completed by Owen Spafford (violin), Chris Amer and James Mackay (guitars), Tom Gibbs (piano), Ali Watson (double bass) and Stephen Henderson (drums) — to present the compositions making up his latest album, Held in the Dark. (Spafford and Gibbs were replacing Charlie Stewart and Fergus McCreadie, who appear on the album.)
Cecil Sharp House, home of the English Folk Dance & Song Society, set on the fringe of Primrose Hill, is not often a host to jazz; the last time I visited was for a Lol Coxhill memorial concert. But it turned out to be the perfect venue for music inspired, subtly but unmistakeably, by Scottish folk themes, and retaining the song-like element even when making use of the language of contemporary jazz. I might be wrong, but I don’t remember anybody trying this since the drummer Ken Hyder led a band called Talisker in the 1970s, although I suppose you could count Wellins’s big-band suites The Wind that Shakes the Barley and Culloden Moor as being inspired by Scottish history.
The easiest way of putting it is to say that Carmichael is making Scottish music in the way that Jan Garbarek and Trygve Seim are making Norwegian music: something with a different and distinctive flavour, and a strong sense of place, but not tied by national restrictions and never remotely flirting with kitsch. Much of Held in the Dark could be described as tone poetry: the pieces can make you think, if you’re so inclined, of heather and big skies. Last night I loved the way Carmichael made himself just one voice in the ensemble (and a particularly appealing one, with a peat-smoke tone and a beguiling sense of economy), and his use of strummed acoustic guitars on some songs. There was one vivid passage for the two acoustics, the fiddle and the bass that suddenly sounded like the birth of bluegrass, while the alternating passages of skirl and skronk in a tune called “Golden Moon” also disturbed the prevailing mood of pastoral lyricism to satisfying effect before the concert ended with the hushed benediction of the title piece. A good-sized crowd was not hesitant in showing its appreciation.
* Matt Carmichael’s Held in the Dark is available via Bandcamp: https://mattcarmichaelmusic.bandcamp.com/album/held-in-the-dark

