Skip to content

The essential Terri Lyne Carrington

TLC Waiting Game Cover3000R

What does it mean when a critic describes an album as “essential”? After all, you can live a full and satisfying life without ever hearing A Love Supreme, Eli & the Thirteenth Confession or Blood on the Tracks, all of which would justify the conventional use of that epithet. But sometimes it’s the word that’s closest to what you want to suggest. And that’s how it is with Waiting Game by Terri Lyne Carrington + Social Science, an album which looks deep into the soul of 21st century America and comes up with something that, like all the best protest music, locates sparks of hope amid the darkness and despair it portrays.

For those unfamiliar with Carrington, she is a 54-year-old drummer, composer and bandleader noted for her work with Cassandra Wilson, Wayne Shorter, Herbie Hancock and many others. She began playing drums at home in Massachusetts, aged seven, on a kit handed down from her grandfather, who had played with Fats Waller. At 11 she received a scholarship to Berklee College of Music in Boston; at 18 she was in New York and playing at the highest level.

Waiting Game is a suite that, blending songs of protest with cutting-edge African American music, takes its place in the line stretching from Max Roach’s We Insist: Freedom Now Suite through Marvin Gaye’s What’s Going On to Ambrose Akinmusire’s Origami Harvest. To the core six-piece Social Science band — Debo Ray (vocals), Kassa Overall (MC), Morgan Guerin (saxophones, bass, EWI), Matthew Stevens (guitar) and Aaron Parks (piano and keyboards) — Carrington adds guest appearances from singers, rappers and MCs including Mark Kibble, Rapsody, Meshell Ndegeocello, Raydar Ellis and Maimouna Youssef, plus the trumpeter Nicholas Payton, the bassists Esperanza Spalding and Derrick Hodge, and others.

The songs are contributed by all the members of the group. Although the words  — dealing with oppression and the rights of women, gay people, Native Americans, political prisoners (in the widest definition of the term) and others — are often confrontational, the music is easy to love. The grooves are slinky, the textures have a warm glow, the voices often soothe and seduce. While Rapsody fires up “The Anthem” with righteous fervour, Debo Ray croons Joni Mitchell’s “Love” (which applies gender reassignment to the famous verses from 1 Corinthians Ch. 13) with the sweetness of a Minnie Riperton. Stevens’s lucid guitar improvisations are a frequent delight, particularly on his own composition “Over and Sons”, which runs on the kind of perfectly lubricated rollers that would have Donald Fagen purring.

That’s the first CD. There’s a second, containing a 42-minute instrumental suite in four sections, titled “Dreams and Desperate Measures”. It seems to have been improvised by Carrington, Parks, Stevens, Guerin and Spalding, with the addition of a very spare orchestration — by Edmar Colón — for three violinists, a cellist, a clarinetist and a flautist. Ebbing and flowing quite beautifully, slowly changing with the light, it quietly compels the listener’s attention. You feel like you’re sitting in the middle of an intimate conversation, or — in places — a chamber-music version of Bitches Brew.

“Music transcends, breaks barriers, strengthens us, and heals old wounds,” Carrington says in a statement accompanying the album. If that’s a proposition which can ever be proved, here — in an album as good as anything I’ve heard all year — is some persuasive evidence.

* Terri Lyne Carrington will be at Kings Place on Saturday as part of the EFG London Jazz festival, she and Social Science Community performing Waiting Game at a 7pm concert before being joined by British guests — including the saxophonist Soweto Kinch and the trumpeter Emma-Jane Thackray — for a 9pm show. Information:

7 Comments Post a comment
  1. I remember when ‘essential’ entered the music lovers’ vocabulary. Probably activated by the Melody Maker, or Bob Harris on OGWT around 1973. ‘It’s essential listening man!’ Mostly it was used by those who were pushing their personal taste on others, even if they were talking about ‘Blood On The Tracks’ or ‘In A Silent Way’. I liked it best when it was was used ironically, as a bit of a put down… Bloke A, seeking validation, would say proudly, ‘I just got the new Gentle Giant.’ And Bloke B – picture Lee Brilleaux pulling on a smoke and looking down towards the pub’s worn carpet, would ‘respond’, almost under his breath, ‘Yeah [pause] essential.’

    November 12, 2019
    • Tim Adkin #

      Sad to see a gratuitous swipe at the eternally misunderstood Giant – even from such an esteemed and and estimable contributor.In the context Fruup(say) yes but GG? Nah.
      Meantime the Carrington sounds pretty good.

      November 13, 2019
    • GuitarSlinger #

      I’d have to agree with you 100% . The question always coming to mind … Essential according to whom ? The record label ? The artist ? A raft of critics who’ve never so much as stood on a stage never mind recorded an album or written a song / composition ? ( the last coming straight out of the Bob Dylan repertoire )

      The greatest irony … for me at least .. is the fact that I’ve never found any so called ‘ essential ‘ album or listening list worth the time it took to read it … never mind listen to it

      So regardless of the snark and detractors … hear hear and two thumbs up to you good sir for having the stones to call ‘ essential ‘ what it is . An opinion one may ( or more likely not ) agree with … making it nonessential at best

      November 15, 2019
  2. That’s me: always pushing my personal taste on others.

    November 12, 2019
    • GuitarSlinger #

      Which is in essence the very definition of your job . Expressing your opinion and promoting your personal tastes to others who may or may not always agree with you . BUT … your opinions once ‘ trusted ‘ do help one to discover new music that may of slipped under their radar .

      The difference between your opinions/reviews … and these so called ‘ essential ‘ collections ? You good sir are not trying to sell us something . You’re recommending it … based on your personal tastes …

      .. which in case the fact has eluded you due to my overt Robert Hughes / LJKS / HST tendencies …. I do fully respect … even when I may vehemently disagree

      .. which is why I come here

      FYI ; Never been a TLC fan and no doubt never will be so I couldn’t care less about this ‘ essential ‘ collection…. that isn’t . But that’s my ( never ever humble ) opinion !

      November 15, 2019
  3. Paul Crowe #

    Sounds like an early present to myself. Thanks, Richard.

    November 13, 2019
  4. geoffn #

    A great curtain-raiser to Saturday’s concert.

    TLC’s 2015 Perfection with David Murray and Geri Allen is also worth hearing. This mighty trio appeared at the LJF the following year; it must have been Allen’s last appearance in London. She is much missed.

    November 14, 2019

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: