Skip to content

And on drums, Jimi Hendrix…

Stevie Wonder can play the drums (listen to “Creepin'”). So can Paul McCartney, after a fashion (“Maybe I’m Amazed”). But I didn’t know that Jimi Hendrix knew how to use a pair of sticks, too.

The proof is in American Drummers 1959-88, Val Wilmer’s new book of 36 photographs of drummers she has observed on and off the stage — and in the case of Hendrix (the only one of her subjects better known for something else), during a sound-check before his show with the Experience at the Royal Albert Hall in London on November 14, 1967.

It’s tempting to assume that Hendrix was just messing around when he sat behind Mitch Mitchell’s kit and picked up a pair of his sticks. But the photo is the evidence that he knew what he was doing. He was left-handed, of course. And he’s holding his right-hand stick in the way that a right-handed drummer would hold his left stick, were he using what is known as the orthodox grip, in which the stick rests in the cradle formed by the clefts between the thumb and forefinger and the second and third fingers.

You can see it on the opposite page in the photo of Andrew Cyrille, a great jazz drummer who has played with Cecil Taylor and many others. Cyrille is a high accomplished technician and most of the time he uses the orthodox grip. The alternative is the matched grip, in which both hands hold the sticks in the same way, as if (to make a crude analogy) they were saucepan handles. Charlie Watts used the orthodox style, Ringo Starr the matched grip.

Drummers sometimes switch from orthodox to matched when they want a particular kind of power — playing the Bo Diddley beat, for instance. And it’s the way most people who aren’t drummers hold the sticks if they’re given the chance to hit something.

But Hendrix is unmistakably using the orthodox grip, which set me thinking. Did he learn it from someone who played drums in one of the bands he’d been in, backing the Isley Brothers and others? Or from Mitch Mitchell, whose early leaning was towards jazz? That seems a bit unlikely to me. You don’t generally learn the orthodox grip unless there’s a very good reason.

So it sent me back to his days in the US Army, drafted into the 101st Airborne Division (the “Screaming Eagles”) in 1961 as an alternative to a jail sentence for joyriding in stolen cars when he was still in his teens. He hated it and lasted barely a year, given a discharge after breaking his ankle in a parachute jump. The only reference I can find to musical involvement during that year was when he asked his father in a letter from Fort Campbell on the Kentucky-Tennessee border to send him the guitar he’d left at a girlfriend’s house in Seattle.

But what if he’d been given the chance to join a marching band, and received basic tuition in playing a shoulder-slung snare drum? That would require a mastery of the orthodox grip, because that’s what it was invented for. And although it might seem at first to be awkward and unnatural, once you learn it, it never goes away.

Val’s photos are full of all the qualities that make her work so special (and which I wrote about when she had an exhibition last year). Yes, there are pictures here of musicians playing on stage — Philly Joe Jones, Max Roach, Kenny Clarke, Tony Williams, Billy Higgins, Elvin Jones, Milford Graves — but also in other, different moments: Sunny Murray reading the paper, Marquis Foster getting his drums out of the trunk of his car, Denis Charles loosening up with a practice pad.

And there are other stories, hidden and half-hidden. A well known New Orleans drummer called Freddie Kohlman is pictured playing a snare drum with the Onward Brass Band at a funeral in 1972. Val told me this week that Kohlman — who died in 1990, aged 75 — had told her how the fledgling Motown label had paid for him, and one or two others, to travel to Detroit to teach the company’s studio musicians how to play the New Orleans rhythms that were the basis of R&B and rock and roll.

Musicians trusted Val, so she could capture them in less formal settings. Below you can see a scene in the Professional Percussion Center on New York’s Eighth Avenue one day in 1971, with the proprietor, Frank Ippolito (who played with Glenn Miller’s Army Air Force Band during WW2), behind the counter, chatting to a trio of customers.

On the left is “Papa” Jo Jones, whose work with Count Basie in the 1930s survives somewhere within the work of every jazz drummer today. In the middle is Jeff Williams, a 21-year-old Berklee graduate from Ohio about to embark on a professional career with the bands of Lee Konitz and Stan Getz (and who has been based for many years in the UK, teaching at the Royal Academy of Music and the Birmingham Conservatoire). On the right is Oliver Jackson, one of Papa Jo’s acolytes, an underrated player with a sense of swing to match that of Roach, Higgins or Frank Butler, as you can hear if you listen to King Curtis’s “Da Duh Dah”.

Just a bunch of guys shooting the breeze in a drum shop one day half a century ago. And, like a lot of Val’s photos, it invites us to share the privileged access that produced this lovely little book.

* Val Wilmer’s American Drummers 1959-1988 is published by Café Royal Books (caferoyalbooks.com), price £6.70.

18 Comments Post a comment
  1. patcherone's avatar

    Do not overlook Richard Manuel! He was Leon’s favorite drummer. He played as if he’d fallen into his kit, and he kept his groove goin’ while he was tryin’ to regain his balance. AMAZING WORK…

    “Conduct yourselves in a manner worthy of the gospel of Christ.” (Phil.1:27 / NASB)

    July 30, 2024
  2. Peter Brown's avatar
    Peter Brown #

    That could only have been written by a drummer! Well done, Richard. I didn’t know any of it.

    July 30, 2024
  3. Bob Davenport's avatar

    I was delighted to discover recently that the V&A has over 60 of Val Wilmer’s photographs: https://collections.vam.ac.uk/search/?page=2&page_size=50&q=%22val+wilmer%22

    July 30, 2024
    • Dave Heasman's avatar
      Dave Heasman #

      Is that really Bob Davenport?

      Of Calthorpe, late of 143 Grays Inn Road?

      Riverboat is asking.

      July 30, 2024
  4. AnEarful's avatar
    AnEarful #

    Great piece about what sounds like a great book! About Hendrix, I’m fairly certain that’s him playing the extensive hi hat solo on Side 3 of Electric Ladyland, based both on how it sounds and the picture of him playing a hi hat in the gatefold. I could be wrong, but it makes even more sense now!

    July 30, 2024
  5. AnEarful's avatar
    AnEarful #

    Great piece about what sounds like a great book! As for Hendrix, I’m fairly certain that’s him playing the extensive hi hat solo on Side 3 of Electric Ladyland. I base this both on how it sounds (a bit looser than Mitchell) and the picture of Jimi playing the hi hat that appears in the gatefold of the album. I could be wrong, but it makes even more sense now!

    July 30, 2024
  6. John Kieffer's avatar
    John Kieffer #

    Looking forward to this book! Chick Corea and Prince were no slouches on the traps too

    July 30, 2024
  7. Patrick Hinely's avatar
    Patrick Hinely #

    Val Wilmer has a unique eye, encompassing the poetic and the historical, yielding a style both creative and documentary. I am always glad to see more of her work appearing in print.

    July 31, 2024
  8. Bill White's avatar
    Bill White #

    Ah Frank Ippolito’s the drum store out of which Joe Jones, Elvin Jones and Tony Williams could all be found teaching in the 1970s. Also the home,a few years earlier, of the invention of the now ubiquitous chain drive bass drum pedal (History Of The Camco Chain Drive Drum Pedal – DRUM! Magazine) I ordered Ms.Wilmer’s book immediately.

    July 31, 2024
  9. micksteels's avatar
    micksteels #

    One of my favourite drummers Oliver Jackson understated but always swinging. A good example of his art is on the Billy Strayhorn cut Cue’s Blue Now with a bunch of Duke’s men, complete with a perfectly timed vocal interjection of Oooh Turn me loose

    July 31, 2024
  10. Chris Walsh's avatar
    Chris Walsh #

    When Keith Jarrett’s Standards trio played a gig, Jarrett would take the drum stool during the sound check, while Jack de Johnette (a very good pianist) would take piano.

    August 1, 2024
  11. CHRISTOPHER WELCH WELCH's avatar
    CHRISTOPHER WELCH WELCH #

    I shall buy this book immediately! Thank you Richard – and Val.

    August 3, 2024
  12. deepindercheema's avatar
    deepindercheema #

    The MM did a series called ‘Play an Instrument Month’ and at Week One 28th Oct 1967 someone interviewed Jimi, Syd, Trower, Noel and Alan Trosser. Jimi says: “As a very young boy I started my musical career playing drums and bass around the Seattle area but when I was 15 I decided it was the guitar for me. So Jimi knew how to hold the sticks. I hope they were Vincent Beldon sticks.

    August 5, 2024
  13. Al Sagginario's avatar
    Al Sagginario #

    McCartney played all of the instruments on his eponymous solo album, including drums. I’m not a McCartney fan but you shouldn’t be so snarky, or maybe you should just be better informed before writing an article.

    December 1, 2024
    • Richard Williams's avatar

      Well, Mr Sagginario, of course we can disagree on the finer points of McCartney’s drumming. Better informed? As it happens, I wrote the Melody Maker review of his ‘eponymous solo album’ when it came out in April 1970 (check the album’s Wikipedia entry, if you want). I think I know enough about how it was made.

      December 1, 2024
      • ALDO NAPOLITANO's avatar
        ALDO NAPOLITANO #

        You may have known it but, you didn’t express it.

        December 5, 2024
      • Richard Williams's avatar

        That’s because I wasn’t writing about it.

        December 5, 2024

Leave a reply to Bob Davenport Cancel reply