Skip to content

Lou Reed 1942-2013 (2)

Lou Reed:MM

You might feel you’ve read enough about Lou Reed in the last couple of days (and here is my Guardian obituary), but here are a few last thoughts.


You’ll have heard a lot about how difficult it was to interview Lou successfully. Without wishing to criticise my colleagues, it always seemed to me that the journalists who had a hard time with him were the ones who felt he owed them answers to questions he had already been asked a million times. I mean, “Were you really on heroin when you wrote ‘Heroin’?” — asked 40 years after the fact — was unlikely to elicit a positive reaction.

Not to say that he was a little ray of sunshine even in the most propitious circumstances. But, like a lot of artists, he preferred contemplating the present and anticipating the future to raking over the past. He was proud of the early stuff, but you can tell just by reading the later interviews that he didn’t want to spend his life discussing it. He usually responded well to people who showed that they had taken the trouble to keep track of what he had been up to in the years since the achievements that brought him his legendary status. If an interviewer wanted to talk about Ornette Coleman (as Bob Elms did on Radio London) or Tibetan philosophy (as Mick Brown did in the Telegraph), he was likely to show genuine enthusiasm and engage in something resembling a real dialogue.

I suppose I was lucky to get to him before the period that began when Transformer and “Walk on the Wild Side” made him a hot act, the point at which large numbers of reporters started to interrogate him. He hadn’t yet met David Bowie — and might not even have heard of him — when I sat down with him at the Inn on the Park in London one day in mid-January, 1972.

He was in London to record his first solo album, accompanied by his producer, Richard Robinson, and Richard’s wife, Lisa, then the New York correspondent of Disc and Music Echo. The Robinsons were friends of mine and they knew I was a Velvet Underground fan of long standing, and soon after their arrival we all had lunch together at the hotel. Lou was quiet and a little preoccupied but perfectly good company.

A few weeks later, after they’d recorded and mixed most of the album with a very heterogeneous bunch of English musicians at Morgan Studios in Willesden (where Rod Stewart had cut Every Picture Tells a Story), I sat down with Lou in his room to listen to some of the near-completed tracks, with the intention of writing a piece for the Melody Maker. It was a very congenial experience. He was so relaxed and willing to talk about his past that when I read the piece now, I feel guilty that I didn’t convey more of his thoughts about the new material. As things turned out, the album — called Lou Reed — created barely a ripple of public interest; soon to be overshadowed by Transformer and his liaison with Bowie, it acquired the dismal aura of a failed project. Give it a proper listen today, however, and you’ll find that “Wild Child”, “Love Makes You Feel” and “Ride into the Sun” are more than worth their place in his canon.

At one point I asked him about the Velvets’ third album, and if he would be willing to support my theory, aired in a review when it came out in 1969, that its 10 songs constituted a single narrative. He seemed delighted. “I’ve never known whether it worked for other people,” he said. “I’ve always written with the idea of putting songs into concepts so that they relate to one another. I always thought of these like chapters in a novel, and that if you played the first three albums all in order, it would really make huge total sense. No one ever seemed to pick up on that, and why should they? I don’t put out that many albums anyway, so by the time Chapter Three arrived, you had to go running back to the archives to find where Chapter Two left off.”

When the song on Lou Reed called “Berlin” mutated, a couple of years later, into the entire album called Berlin, with its cast of characters and single continuous and coherent narrative, he seemed to have achieved his ambition to make a rock and roll album that worked like a novel.


No doubt there will be a great deal of reassessment of Reed’s work in the coming years. Given the way the once-despised Berlin was rehabilitated, don’t bet against something similar happening to Lulu — his recent album with Metallica, even more voceriferously despised by US critics — one day. I’ve been listening to it over the past 24 hours, and it seems to me that anyone who claims to adore the harsher moments of White Light/White Heat yet dismisses this one needs to have a serious rethink.

A more likely beneficiary, however, could be Songs for Drella, the album he made with John Cale for Sire in 1990 as a farewell to Andy Warhol, their former patron. Originally performed at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, it’s a biography in music, beginning with Warhol’s origins as a youthful misfit in Pittsburgh and tracing the story through his early days as an advertising artist and his rise to prominence as a succes de scandale in the New York art world of the 1960s to Valerie Solanas’s attempt to kill him and his eventual death from a heart attack following gallbladder surgery in 1987.

Reed and Cale were close to Warhol, but their view of his world is as clear-sighted and illuminating as it is generous and affectionate. Musically, it gains impact from its sense of intimacy: the instrumentation is restricted to Reed’s guitars and Cale’s various keyboards and viola. They both sing, the simplicity of the surroundings highlighting the restrained emotion in their voices. There’s a lot of contrast, effectively employed, like the jump from the elegance of Cale accompanied by strings on the delicate “Style It Takes” to Reed’s rapid-fire delivery over the chattering keyboard and buzz-saw guitar of “Work”, but the whole song-cycle coheres beautifully, forming a perceptive and touching tribute to a man who played a significant role in their careers. It’s easy to imagine its reputation increasing as the years pass.


If you don’t already know it, try to hear Lou’s version of Doc Pomus and Mort Shuman’s “This Magic Moment”, included in a CD called Till the Night Is Gone: A Tribute to Doc Pomus, issued in 1998 by Forward/Rhino. The album features a stellar cast — Dylan, B.B. King, Brian Wilson, Irma Thomas, Los Lobos, Roseanne Cash, Dr John, Aaron Neville, Dion, Solomon Burke, etc — but his track is a standout. Originally a Top 20 hit for the Drifters in 1960,  it allows him to demonstrate both his deep affection for R&B and his gift for stripped-down rock and roll, his two guitar parts — one skirling, the other snarling  — accompanied by Fernando Saunders on bass and George Recile on drums. And he really was among the most unorthodox and creative of rock guitarists, a fact often overlooked in the desire to acclaim his more headline-friendly characteristics.

13 Comments Post a comment
  1. As others have said before me Richard, your take on Lou Reed is perhaps the most insightful, knowledgeable, and thereby gratifying, that have tripped across our screens since his passing. I for one have been listening to his canon with fresh ears. Often, this new-found interest in recently deceased artists can be perceived as a kind of mawkish bandwagon-jumping. But it is an entirely natural response. It is in the human condition to take what is always there for granted, and miss it when it’s gone. But while the man has left us, the music remains, and we, the living, have the luxury of days to drink it in with the perspective of history, and appreciate it anew.

    October 30, 2013
  2. I’m in complete agreement: there’s nothing mawkish about it. It always makes me go and listen to the things I might have missed or to which I paid insufficient attention. Only good can come of that. And thanks for the kind words.

    October 30, 2013
  3. #

    Glad that you’ve given Songs for Drella the attention which it so deserves.

    October 30, 2013
  4. Clive Robertson #

    My old (performance art) friend, Keith Wood suggested I read your blog Richard and it is a real pleasure to do so. You write with unusual care and insight about a shared past and for that we are more than lucky. Clive Robertson, former editor/publisher FUSE magazine, Executive Producer, Voicespondence Artists Records and Tapes.Kingston, Canada.

    October 30, 2013
  5. geoffnoble #

    I’m glad you mentioned Songs for Drella here and in the obituary. Spare, intense and often moving, the album represents the best of both Reed and Cage. There is some good live footage on youtube.

    October 30, 2013
    • geoffnoble #

      For Cage, of course read Cale.

      October 30, 2013
  6. Peter F #

    Agree about Ride Into The Sun – I was a very junior engineer at Morgan at the time and have a vivid memory of Steve Howe overdubbing that fine solo in one take, after one listen to the track, just astonished all present. He wanted to have another stab at it, Lou & Richard were very sure that he’d done more than enough. Subsequent takes got tidier, but not better!

    October 30, 2013
  7. Thanks for this and the great obituary in The Guardian. Readers might be interested to know that Lou’s fine version of This Magic Moment was originally on the Lost Highway OST & a French blog has it to stream or download at

    October 30, 2013
  8. No reason we would get tired of reading about Lou Reed when the writing is this clear-eyed, free of shibboleth, and full of genuine affection. Thanks.

    October 30, 2013
  9. Quite by chance I listened to Songs For Drella and Lou Reed’s debut in the last couple of days, and wholly agree that they are underrated. I will now seek out the Metallica collaboration. Thanks, Richard, for your perceptive writing on a great artist.

    October 30, 2013
  10. Thanks for this, Richard – a really valuable and interesting corrective to prevailing mis-remembrances. Journalists who write/talk about the questions they didn’t get answered are like plumbers telling you about the leaks they weren’t skilful enough to fix… Not sure if you will have seen it, but indie sage @richard_king took a similarly astute position from an 80’s-90’s perspective and of course let us not forget the delight of Lou’s egg cream which took us (and him) back to his novelty dance single roots in fine style

    October 31, 2013
  11. There’s a very nice, stripped down version of One For My Baby here – – with Lou on guitar and Rob Wasserman on bass.

    November 3, 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: