Skip to content

Defying gravity

It’s easy to imagine the director Dorsay Alavi going all the way through an alphabetical list of Wayne Shorter’s compositions while looking for a suitable title for her three-part documentary on the life and work of the great saxophonist and composer, and knowing when she reached “Zero Gravity” that she’d got it. As such bio-docs on jazz musicians go, Wayne Shorter: Zero Gravity is something of a masterpiece. The title expresses the subject’s unique characteristic, present in his music and in his conversation, as I found while interviewing him in his London hotel room for the Melody Maker in 1972, during Weather Report’s three-week season at Ronnie Scott’s. Here’s how the piece started:

“I hate to talk about music,” Wayne Shorter said. So we didn’t — at least, not really. For instance, we talked about the navigation of ships. Wayne showed me several large books on the subject, told me he was hoping to study it seriously, and then unrolled a sheet of score-paper on which he’d written a new composition called “Celestial Navigator”, based on the feelings gathered from his discoveries.

We talked about the sacred figures of Brazil — like the Lady of the Sea. If you see her, Wayne said, she she sees you, then you don’t live to tell the tale. But she serves people from the sea, too, and every Brazilian home contains her picture. And he showed me another piece, named after her.

And so it went on, through an hour or so of conversation which I can only compare to the experience of talking to Ornette Coleman, Don Van Vliet (Captain Beefheart) or Van Dyke Parks. The interviewee is operating on a different plane of thought and expression, and your best plan is to keep out of the way and let their logic take its own trajectory. Of course that doesn’t always work. Sometimes you can’t help trying to drag them back to earth. Yet at such moments Shorter remained gracious. Here’s more:

Although he didn’t really want to discuss it, I asked him why he left Miles Davis. “After six years with Miles it was becoming… that living cycle, that seven-year itch thing, came around. I knew had to take a year off, at least. My wife and I moved around, spending the summer in a town house in New York, where I could think about how to get rid of that sound I had with Miles, to get the sound of the musicians, and the compositions I wrote during that time, out of my head.

“I wanted to rid myself of any one association — so that people can look at anything new that I do with a bit of objectivity, without connecting me with Miles or Art Blakey, as everyone always has.” It wasn’t always easy for him to take his sabbatical. “Miles would call me up and ask if I wanted to make a record date, or write something for his band, and I had to refuse because it was necessary for me to break that connection completely.”

He talked about his most recent Blue Note album, Super Nova, and its projected successor, Odyssey of Iska, dedicated to his younger daughter, and about his enthusiasm for the Brazilian singer Milton Nascimento (who would be featured on Native Dancer, his first album for Columbia, in 1975). And he spoke warmly, of course, about Weather Report:

“I’d always had the feeling that it would be nice to have a band in which everybody would hold their own and have a leader’s responsibility. We’re all responsible to many different obligations, which is much better than when one man is responsible for everyone’s obligations. We can do more, musically. It was hard to find a bunch of musicians who were prepared to stop playing like they used to.”

That last remark is the kind of thing that pops up throughout Zero Gravity: little maxims, like Zen koans, that open the mind to new ways of thinking about old subjects, some of them adapted from Davis, his former boss. “Play like you don’t know how to play” is one. Search for “music that doesn’t sound like music” and “Jazz means, ‘I dare you'” are others. Danilo Perez, the pianist with his quartet, remembers being given a large pile of new compositions, and on asking Shorter when they were going to find the time to rehearse them, getting the reply: “You can’t rehearse the unknown.”

The first of Zero Gravity‘s three hour-long episodes deals with his early years, from a New Jersey childhood to the great Davis Quintet, the director taking the chance of using two young actors in wordless imaginative reconstructions of his boyhood with his brother Al. The second part examines with the period of Weather Report’s great success, the reasons behind the group’s dissolution, his work with Joni Mitchell, and the personal tragedies he encountered during those years, including the deaths of Iska and her mother, Ana Maria Patricio, his second wife, and of Al, his brother.

The final part deals with the music of his last 20 years: the wonderful quartet with Perez, the bassist John Patitucci and the drummer Brian Blade, the orchestral pieces, and the opera, Iphigenia, written and performed with Esperanza Spalding. Her presence in the film, along with that of Mitchell and the drummer Terri Lyne Carrington, reminds us that few jazz musicians of his generation were as comfortable as Shorter with the idea that female musicians could have equal standing within the music.

Shorter’s love of fairy tales and science fiction, in part ignited by early exposure to Charles Kingsley’s The Water Babies, is also featured as part of an exploration of the character of a man who retained a child’s sense of wonder throughout the life that ended last March, in his 90th year on the planet. The animations and flights of visual imagination that appear throughout the film, alongside many fine clips of the Jazz Messengers, the Davis band and the Shorter quartet, make complete sense. Filmed and edited while he was still alive, and thus preserving him in the present tense. Zero Gravity is pretty much the perfect tribute to an extraordinary human being.

* The film Wayne Shorter: Zero Gravity is available on Amazon Prime.

17 Comments Post a comment
  1. Tony F's avatar
    Tony F #

    I don’t use Amazon Prime so I’ll have to find another way to see this – it sounds like essential viewing. I never did see Weather Report, although I have much of what they recorded, but I did get to see the great quartet with Blade, Patitucci and Perez in Birmingham (UK) – I was so pleased I did.

    September 14, 2023
  2. Tim Adkin's avatar
    Tim Adkin #

    Like Tony F I don’t use Amazon Prime but it does sound essential viewing. Shorter’s death is one I’ve really felt this year as marking the passing of an era or something like it (see also Jeff Beck, Pete Brown, Mary Quant and others ). I did see Weather Report (a band I loved), oddly enough in Birmingham, in 1978 at the height of the Pastorius era. They were dreadfully disappointing with showboating all round including Shorter who seemed pretty out of sorts. The stuff with Art and Miles, the Blue Notes, ‘Sweetnighter’, ‘Mysterious Traveller’, the wonderful ‘Native Dancer’ and the aforementioned later quartet, more than make up for one disappointing October night in Brum. Having recently read M. John Harrison’s remarkable ‘The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again’ I really must read ‘The Water Babies’…

    September 14, 2023
  3. Graham Pogson's avatar
    Graham Pogson #

    Thank you Richard for your excellent comments on a brilliant documentary.

    September 14, 2023
  4. zan stewart's avatar

    Beautiful piece, Richard. You really got him, and got that film. As one who has interviewed both Wayne and Ornette, I know exactly what you mean by having to let him go where goes, step out of the way. I once asked Wayne why he wrote “Children of the Night” and his answer must have taken 15 minutes as he went from thought to thought. Really a rare human being. Good work here, but, then, as always. Cheers.

    September 15, 2023
  5. Sedat Nemli's avatar
    Sedat Nemli #

    This is indeed a great documentary. To hear the Wayne Shorter Quartet live – which I was fortunate to on a few occasions – was a spellbinding experience. Confronting the listener with the abstract/unknown, it felt like the natural (if not a more sophisticated) continuation of his latter days with Miles, ultimately making the whole Weather Report era sound more like an aberration.

    September 15, 2023
    • Michael Engelbrecht's avatar
      Michael Engelbrecht #

      „More like an aberration“… i politely disagree. Was Miles‘ „electric period“ culminating in „Agharta“ an aberration? Surely not. If we prefer a certain period of a musician, we shouldn‘t be that disrespectful for another path taken along the way. Albums like „Black Market“ and „Mysterious Traveler“ (both by Weather Report) are stone cold (and elevating) masterpieces of the „fusion era“.

      Maybe i am a bit sensitive here, cause I very well remember Ken Burns‘ documentary on the history of jazz that (in spite of all its merits) turned polemic and dull and simple minded when reflecting „electric Miles“ and „free jazz“. I was happy to see Wayne‘s quartet in Cologne (sublime and beautiful), and Weather Report in their last period in Erlangen, Germany. Even at the end, there was more than a spoonful of magic in the music of WR. Wayne was indeed a „mysterious traveller“. I highly recommend „Odssey Of Iska“, a bit of a bridge between his Blue Note classics and the stylistic „hybrids“ of the 70‘s…

      September 15, 2023
  6. tim hinkley's avatar

    I think you summed it up when you said its a masterpiece Richard. Here we have one of the great “Master Saxophonists” of the era who reached old age, unlike a lot of the great Masters, Sonny Rollins being an exception . This documentary follows Wayne’s path through life.With his Zen attitude taking him on a journey few musicians’s have ever taken. IMHO “Zero Gravity” should be mandatory watching for any aspiring musician as Peter Jackson’s, “Watch The Beatles, Get Back” should be for anyone considering forming a rock band. BTW Richard I have to own up I didn’t read the Robertson piece before I made the comment about the songwriting credits….my anger about this subject has obscured my view…I will take off the blindfold.

    September 15, 2023
  7. Michael Engelbrecht's avatar
    Michael Engelbrecht #

    Years ago, I met Michelle Mercer who had written a book about Wayne Shorter‘s life. She was pressed for time; “Penguin” did not allow her any additional time. The book had to be finished within three months. So she traveled one last time to the American saxophonist, whose interviews are (Richard‘s experience is telling volumes:)) quite cryptic and following bizarre paths. Michelle was used to Wayne’s narratives, without being able to decipher them any faster.

    When Shorter’s wife learned about the time pressure of the journalist, she talked a few bars with her “living legend”, and Wayne from that moment on gave only clear, razor-sharp information: this musician has been running a game for years, he wants to have fun in interviews, improvise, that’s why, he puts on the foolscap!

    After seeing this fine documentary, I put on Wayne‘s „Adam‘s Apple“, and Weather Report‘s excellent „Mysterious Traveller“.

    September 15, 2023
  8. Steve Clarke's avatar
    Steve Clarke #

    Great piece. Thank you. Can’t wait to see the film, especially his work with Mitchell.

    September 15, 2023
  9. Lucy Durán's avatar
    Lucy Durán #

    I always enjoy your posts. As a veteran interviewer/broadcaster and academic-now-retired, I am much inspired by the way you revisit interviews you conducted many years ago and recontextualise and reinterpret them. I particularly like your comment “The interviewee is operating on a different plane of thought and expression, and your best plan is to keep out of the way and let their logic take its own trajectory”. That is advice many more should follow!

    September 15, 2023
    • Michael Engelbrecht's avatar
      Michael Engelbrecht #

      Though I grew up in Germany, dear Lucy, Richard Williams quite early crossed my ways when I read – as a teenager – a lot of his reviews in the Melody Maker. Unforgettable, his triple review titled „Modern Music“ in which he was singing his praise on Brian Eno‘s Music For Films (still awesome), Jan Garbarek‘s „Places“ (still excellent), and – with slight reservations – Weather Report‘s „Mr. Gone“ (though not as brilliant as some of their previous album, still quite a fine work). Like Mikal Gilmore at Downbeat and some writers of the french „Jazz Magazine“ he was never trapped by „zeitgeist“ and fashion. And that exactly made his reviews unforgettable for me.

      September 15, 2023
      • Tim Adkin's avatar
        Tim Adkin #

        Michael, I’m likewise indebted to RW. I guess I’m somewhat older than yourself so for me it was his writings/reviews/interviews with artists as disparate as King Crimson, Van Morrison, The Band, Curtis Mayfield, VDGG, VU and innumerable jazz artists that helped point me in something like the right direction. Three reviews in particular still stand out – summer ’69 and his review of Mike Mantler’s JCOA double (the one with the silver sleeve and the epic Cecil Taylor track) and a couple of years on and his review of The Temptations’ ‘Sky’s the Limit’ album. Then, somewhat more leftfield (in the context of this post) his review of Joe Walsh’s ‘Smoker…’ LP.
        Must listen to ‘Mr Gone’ again – it’s never really grabbed me but I know that Django Bates, for one, swears buy it. Best,T.

        September 15, 2023
      • Michael Engelbrecht's avatar
        Michael Engelbrecht #

        Correction: the title of RW‘s review was „Modern Mood Music“… and, in regards to Tim: „Mr. Gone“ definitely had its moments, by far better was „Tale Spinnin‘“ (from their later works) – a joy to listen to it in surround, for example.

        September 15, 2023
  10. Dr Peter Starie's avatar
    Dr Peter Starie #

    A lovely piece about a great man.

    September 15, 2023
  11. Conal's avatar
    Conal #

    Thanks very much for alerting me to this film and I also very much enjoyed your recollection of meeting WS. I saw him perform with his quartet at Birmingham Symphony Hall in 2012 (I checked and there’s a review of it in the Guardian). It was very much like I imagine seeing Miles at the top of his game(I only saw MD at Nice Jazz Festival towards the end of his life when M wasn’t even if it was still special). WS made no announcements and played quite briefly on both tenor and soprano just making quite short musical interjections just to shape and direct things. When he did play it somehow made complete sense of what the rest of the band had played and were playing and was utterly exquisite and glued everything together. The band played for at least an hour and I can’t remember if there was an encore but I was certainly left yearning for more. It was one of the best concerts I have ever attended. A really transcendent experience.

    September 15, 2023
    • Tony F's avatar
      Tony F #

      God, was that nearly eleven years ago? I was at the same concert. It lives on in my mind as if it was last week. Prompted by your post here, Conal, I went back to that Guardian review, and found that I commented thus at the time:
      “It was truly a privilege to witness WS quartet – demanding yes, but highly rewarding. I wasn’t sure for 10 mins or so – was it me or was it them? But then I relaxed into it and realised that with great art (and this assuredly was), you get what the artist (or in this case, artists) want to do, and not just easy, crowd-pleasing tropes.”
      I don’t think I have been to another concert where I came away with such a strong sense of true art having been collaboratively created there and then, before my eyes and ears.

      September 17, 2023
      • Conal's avatar
        Conal #

        I agree. It does live on vividly in my mind. I am not sure how accurate my memory is but i can see WS standing next to the piano totalling immersed in the music and occasionally consulting something maybe a setlist that he had placed inside it. I think the concert began with a short drum solo that established quite a frenetic rhythm. The band were blowing up a storm and wayne was the calm right at the centre of it. He had distilled everything about his playing down to essentials and i cant remember him playing any of the amazingly fast bebop lines of his youthful years. Although you had the impression that he had lost none of his virtuosity and could play anything he wanted. My friend and i had bought tickets right up in the Gods but because the concert was far from sold out we were able to move down to directly above the piano and where wayne was standing. Wayne had completely absorbed miles’ poeticism and use of space and the ability to elicit supernatural performances by all the band. Back in 2012 you could buy CDs in a little shop in the Hall and i bought the quartet’s latest release since the shop would usually have music for sale by the evening’s performers. I am going to see if i can find it and play it now. Richard can i ask your advice about the best way of buying tickets for berlin jazz festival since i would like to go this year never having been and it doesn’t seem very obvious how you go about this. I also noticed that joshua redman and michael wolny are playing concerts (separately) shortly after the festival but buying tickets online seems very difficult and seems to involve dealing with a ticket agent rather than say berlin philharmonie (perhaps its difgiculy because my german is very poor)?

        September 17, 2023

Leave a reply to Tim Adkin Cancel reply