Skip to content

Flutter and wow


After several books in which he perceptively explored the place and meaning of sound in our lives — including Oceans of Sound, Exotica, Haunted Weather, Sinister Resonance and Into the Maelstrom — now David Toop tells us how he came by his deep love and remarkable understanding of music. Flutter Echo: Living Within Sound, first published two years ago in Japan, where he has a devoted following, is now available in an English edition, and will provide valuable reading for anyone interested in the breadth of Toop’s interests.

That certainly includes me. If Toop is interested in something, the chances are that I will be, too. As signposts to the journey he describes, he appends a list of stuff he liked at the time. The period 1967-70, for instance, when he was in his late teens, includes Junior Wells’s Hoodoo Man Blues, Nico’s The Marble Index, the SME’s Karyobin, and Laura Nyro’s Eli and the Thirteenth Confession. Ten years later he was listening to Little Beaver’s “Party Down”, Cachao y su Descarga, Dr Alimentado’s “Ride on Brother”, Walt Dickerson’s Peace and Evelyn Champagne King’s “Shame”. And so on. Our kind of person, I think.

His book is the story of how a boy from London’s northern suburbs found the music that gave volume, depth and direction to his life. Because his story parallels the experience of so many, and because Toop writes equally well about epiphanies and tragedies, it invites and secures the reader’s empathy.

As a journalist, Toop wrote for many publications (The Face, The Wire and others) and was heavily involved in two magazines, Musics and Collusion, that — among other things — chronicled the activities in the 1970s and early ’80s of the “second generation” of British free improvisers, of whom he was a prominent member, along with his frequent collaborators Steve Beresford, Paul Burwell, Max Eastley, Peter Cusack and others.

Their work is featured in Further Perspectives and Distortions, an excellent three-CD box subtitled “An Encyclopedia of British Experimental and Avant-Garde Music 1976-1984”. Its time-frame means that it includes the wilder work of people associated with jazz-rooted free improvisation, contemporary classical, punk rock and post-punk, from AMM through Gavin Bryars and Alternative TV to This Heat, the Pop Group and Henry Cow. Other mavericks include the Roberts Wyatt and Fripp, Bob Cobbing, Ron Geesin, David Cunningham and Fred Frith.

The way I’ve listened to it is mostly to let each disc run — the tracks are sequenced alphabetically, by artist — and not to bother with checking the origin of each item. Sometimes I couldn’t help myself from wanting to know that a brilliant drum solo was from a Soft Machine track (John Marshall, presumably), or that an irresistible electro-groove was This Hear’s “24 Track Loop”. I enjoyed the 4min 28sec of silence halfway through the second disc, titled “(Extract from) The Compassion and Humanity of Margaret Thatcher” and credited to No Artist.

Those highlights aside (and there are, of course, others), the way I’ve chosen to listen means that the rustlings and bangings and jagged guitars and squeals and howls and pneumatic drilling and rantings and mutterings blend into each other like a mosaic-portrait of an edgy, difficult and often stimulating time, when almost everything was political. Maybe we’re heading that way again.

* The photograph of David Toop is by Fabio Lugaro, and is on the cover of Flutter Echo, which is published by Ecstatic Peace Library. The box set Further Perspectives and Distortions is on the Cherry Red label.

8 Comments Post a comment
  1. Ben Thompson #

    Delighted to see this excellent book getting some of the attention it deserves. Here is Mr Toop reading excerpts from it to live mixed accompaniment (including a bit of Max Bygraves he wasn’t expecting but that’s what mispresses can do for you)

    December 20, 2019
  2. Sara #

    What a great writer you are, Richard. The (silent) Compassion and Humanity of Margaret Thatcher’ made our Saturday morning cup of tea in bed, as we get ready to face another day with Johnson as PM. Last night we went to a screening of Cinderella: The Shoe Must Go On and Spitting Image: the Panto, with an intro by the great Barry Cryer and Steve Nallon, the voice of Margaret Thatcher on Spitting Image.
    Steve said Spitting Image was really the only visible opposition to the Thatcher Government at the time. I can’t imagine it being remade for this government, though we need it more than ever.

    December 21, 2019
    • Sara #

      I should have written that Steve Nallon was quoting a Spitting Image fan who told him that it was the only visible opposition to Thatcher. Steve said he was moved by the fan who said that

      December 21, 2019
  3. Chris Walsh #

    I assume that Compassion and Humanity couldn’t run for an additional 5 seconds for fear of John Cage’s lawyers descending heavily on their heads.

    December 21, 2019
    • Paul Crowe #

      Am I having a memory breakdown or did the Electric Flag “do a John Cage” with a track titled “World War Three Blues ” ?

      December 21, 2019
  4. Tim Adkin #

    The West Coast Pop Art Experimental Band (a name in itself redolent of a whole era) did ‘Anniversary for World War III’ (which was 90 odd seconds of silence) at the end of one of their platters.
    Good to see mention of the wonderful This Heat too.

    December 21, 2019
  5. Trevor Barre #

    Don’t forget the Toop compilations on CD (Guitars from Mars, was it?) and his New and Rediscovered Instruments, a booklet from 1974 or thereabouts.

    December 23, 2019
  6. There was a few – Oceans of Sound, Crooning At Venus, Electro For Droids. All excellent.

    December 31, 2019

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: