Asha Puthli at the Barbican
The 2006 EFG London Jazz Festival got off to slightly strange start for me. Why did I buy a ticket for Asha Puthli’s concert at the Barbican Hall? Curiosity, mostly. Because I’d interviewed her back in 1972, out of an interest in meeting the person Ornette Coleman had invited to sing on a couple of tracks of Science Fiction, his recently released LP, and because last night’s guest artists included the trumpeter Yazz Ahmed, the sitarist Anoushka Shankar and the tabla drummer Sarathy Korwar.
To be frank, I hadn’t kept tabs on Puthli over the past five decades, although I knew that she’d featured in the disco and fashion worlds. What I remember of meeting her was that she came from a privileged background in Bombay (now Mumbai), studied the tarana style of Hindustani classical singing from childhood, fell in love with jazz, arrived in New York in 1969 with scholarship to study dance with Martha Graham, and told me, in startlingly explicit terms, a story about being propositioned by a well-known free jazz musician (not Coleman).
Last night’s concert was billed as a “Cosmic Voyage”, and I had no idea what that might entail. I lasted an hour, during which Puthli — now 81 — turned up looking and sounding like a cross between Dame Edna Everage (diamante-encrusted spectacles), Daphne Guinness (extreme fashion sense), Amanda Lear (Studio 54 vibe), and Mae West (occasional dirty wisecrack). She fumbled through the running order and required reminders to introduce her guests, and her singing was not strong, needing the help she received from a supporting female singer.
Her six-piece band kept things in order, providing a platform for the cut-and-paste contributions of her guests. Ahmed played a couple of poised trumpet and flugelhorn solos, Shankar shredded — I think that’s the right term — on a cover of Bobby Hebb’s “Sunny”, and Korwar’s brief showcase suggested to me what a concert been devoted solely to the three guests might have achieved.
I don’t really know what the “Cosmic Journey” was all about, or what the almost-capacity audience was thinking as they laughed along at her semi-audible jokes. Maybe it all became clear after the interval. The man across the aisle who came as Truman Capote certainly seemed to enjoy himself. But I thought of other performances I’ve witnessed by female singers in their seventies and eighties, and I remembered how Mabel Mercer and Mavis Staples in particular could work around the inevitable loss of technical resources and still express their essence. That, I’m afraid, didn’t seem to be happening here.










